How Do You Know if Your Sales Strategy is Broken?

How Do You Know if Your Sales Strategy is Broken?

By Frank Hurtte

Many distributors struggle when asked to explain their sales strategy. With a great deal of hand waving and stuttering, the conversation quickly turns vague and squishy. Sales leaders talk about relationships, service, responsiveness, and “taking care of the customer.” All important, of course. No customer enjoys working with an unresponsive supplier or a company that creates problems instead of solving them.

But those statements rarely explain why customers actually buy.

Listen closely, and you’ll hear familiar catchphrases:

• “Our strength is our relationships.”
• “Our people care more than the other guys.”
• “We give great service.” (What does that even mean?)
• “We go above and beyond supplier expectations.”

True? Possibly. Strategic? Not even close. You can bet your bottom dollar that every competitor can make the same claim

There’s a simpler way to test the strength of a sales strategy. Instead of debating slogans, ask the million‑dollar question:

Why do your customers buy from you?

The answer reveals more about a distributor’s real strategy than any strategic planning document ever written.

A knowledge‑based sales strategy produces a completely different set of answers. When a distributor creates measurable value, customers describe the relationship in terms of outcomes, not personalities.

Customers might say:

• “They helped us reduce downtime.”
• “They simplified our maintenance process.”
• “They eliminated the need for outside contractors.”
• “They improved our production throughput.”
• “They helped us reduce safety incidents.”

These answers reflect something fundamentally different than the responses above. They describe operational and economic impact. Instead of talking about how pleasant the distributor is to work with, the customer explains how the distributor improves the performance of their business. That distinction matters more than many sellers realize.

Customer value ultimately falls into eight categories, each aligned with common accounting practices. Suppliers create value when they help customers:

1. Replace internal labor with more efficient solutions
2. Reduce reliance on outside contractors
3. Lower operating expenses
4. Reduce assets tied up in inventory or equipment
5. Increase revenue or throughput
6. Improve market position
7. Enhance safety and reduce workplace risk
8. Strengthen company culture

Customers remember distributors/suppliers who improve these outcomes. These suppliers become more than convenient vendors. They become partners who enhance the customer’s business performance.

Unfortunately, most distributors never reach this level. Instead, they continue relying on relationship‑driven selling, which creates several structural problems:

• Price pressure increases because value is difficult to quantify.
• Discounts become easier to justify as a means of “protecting the relationship.”
• Salespeople defend their effort instead of the economic results delivered to the customer.
• CRM systems track activity but rarely capture measurable value.
• Revenue becomes tied to personalities rather than a competitive strategy.

It’s a fragile position for the distributor.
When a salesperson retires, changes companies, or loses a key relationship, the account becomes vulnerable. The distributor suddenly discovers its revenue was built on personal relationships rather than a repeatable value proposition.

The responsibility for changing this situation ultimately falls on the distributor leadership. Knowledge‑based selling doesn’t appear by accident. Salespeople rarely begin talking about operational impact or financial value unless the distributor leadership team makes it clear that these conversations matter and begins to tie them into performance measurements.

Leaders must teach salespeople to ask better questions: questions about operations, financial drivers, and future direction. They must insist that sellers understand how the customer’s business actually works. Sales coaching should focus on identifying value drivers, not simply asking whether the salesperson visited the customer or showed a product.

Sales manager questions should include:

• “What problem did we solve for the customer?”
• “How did we improve their operations?”
• “What economic impact did our solution create?”

When these questions become part of everyday conversations, the sales organization begins to shift. Salespeople must be pushed, prodded, and encouraged to do more than describe a catalog of products and instead dwell on the intrinsic value to the customer.

The conversation changes from “What does this cost?” to “What does this change?”

This shift transforms the sales guy’s mindset. Instead of representing a catalog, they become a resource for operational insight and measurable improvement.

Sales leaders can test the strength of their strategy with one simple exercise: Ask your sales team why customers buy from you.

Then listen carefully. Do the answers focus on relationships and effort? Or do they describe measurable improvements in the customer’s business?

The answers reveal the truth. Being liked is valuable. Being responsive is important. Providing good service is basic table stakes. But none of these represent a durable competitive advantage.

A real strategy emerges when customers can clearly describe how your company improves their business. At that point, the salesperson isn’t just pleasant to work with; they become economically difficult to replace.

If you want your sales team to shift from relationship‑based selling to measurable, value‑driven impact, River Heights Consulting can help. We teach distributors how to uncover customer value, communicate it clearly, and build strategies that are impossible to replace. Let’s talk about strengthening your sales approach.

TL;DR
If your sales team explains customer loyalty using relationships and effort, your strategy is weak. If customers describe measurable operational and financial improvements, you have a real, durable competitive advantage.

Author Bio 
Frank Hurtte has spent decades helping distributors move beyond “friendly and
responsive” to strategies that actually grow revenue. He believes every salesperson can learn to talk about value, even the ones who still think CRM stands for “Can’t Remember Much.”

If you want a shortcut to understanding where AI fits in distribution, this is a great start.

...